
Columbus Nonprofit Sanctuary Night Held in Contempt Over Nuisance Agreement Violations
Columbus, Ohio – Sanctuary Night, a nonprofit based in Columbus, Ohio, has been held in contempt of court after failing to comply with a court-approved nuisance agreement intended to curb illegal activity and safety concerns at its Franklinton facility.
On April 30, the City of Columbus—through City Attorney Zach Klein—filed a nuisance lawsuit against the organization, located at 1195 Sullivant Avenue. The lawsuit cited open drug use, criminal activity, and prostitution as ongoing issues affecting the surrounding community.
A resolution was reached on May 7 when both parties agreed on specific corrective measures. These included banning drugs and alcohol on-site, installing police-recommended security features, reducing loitering, and serving only women-identifying clients.
However, according to court filings, Sanctuary Night blocked a city inspector from performing a required inspection on May 15, delaying entry until most clients had vacated. This action prevented timely verification of compliance.
As a result, Judge Stephanie Mingo ruled Sanctuary Night in contempt on May 23. City Attorney’s Office spokesperson Pete Shipley stated that ongoing monitoring will continue, with legal consequences if the nonprofit fails to meet its obligations.
Despite the legal action, Mayor Andrew Ginther reaffirmed the city’s commitment to supporting Sanctuary Night’s mission, saying, “They do vital work, but everyone must operate responsibly and be a good neighbor.”
The next court hearing is scheduled for July 24. The organization has yet to issue an official statement.