Grandmother Mourns 6-Year-Old Eva Bretz – her mother faces murder charges
Columbus, Ohio – A heartbreaking tragedy has left the community grieving after 6-year-old Eva Bretz died under disturbing circumstances. Grandmother Darcy Bretz mourns the loss of her beloved granddaughter as the child’s mother, Ashley Fagan, faces murder charges.
Eva was a vibrant, artistic girl who loved drawing, dancing, and performing. Her grandmother recalls the special bond they shared, saying, “I called her my angel from the moment I met her.” Most weekends were spent at Darcy’s home, where Eva found joy, safety, and creativity.
On April 13, Eva was taken to Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus in critical condition with severe injuries, including a severed liver and ligature marks. She died just hours later. Authorities ruled her death a homicide, and court records indicate disturbing abuse.
Eva’s mother, Ashley Fagan, and her boyfriend Blake Hutchinson were charged with murder and child endangerment. Both reportedly gave false statements about how Eva was injured. Hutchinson died by suicide as police attempted to arrest him.
Darcy’s grief is compounded by disbelief and regret. “That weekend, the only one in a long time she wasn’t with me… I wish I had been there,” she said.
Franklin County Children Services (FCCS) confirmed they had multiple past reports involving Eva’s family, dating back to 2019. Allegations included substance exposure and neglect. While prior cases were closed, a case concerning one of Eva’s siblings remained open at the time of her death.
FCCS released a statement acknowledging that support services had not succeeded in preventing isolation — a factor that can obscure signs of abuse.
Darcy blames both the system and Eva’s mother. “I think it was 100% preventable,” she said.
If you suspect child abuse or neglect in your community, call Franklin County Children Services at 614-229-7000.
Follow Dalmar TV on Facebook for the Latest News
